Understanding the SEC’s Framework Proposal
On December 23, 2020, the SEC made waves by proposing a framework for broker-dealers to custody digital asset securities. But don’t get too excited – this isn’t a free-for-all. Instead, they’ve laid down some mighty strict conditions that can only be described as both a roadmap and a potential minefield.
The Key Conditions for Custodying Digital Assets
To start, broker-dealers must limit their activities exclusively to digital asset securities. No cross-pollination with traditional securities, folks! Among the demands are:
- Restrict Business Activities: Exclusively processing digital asset securities only.
- Robust Policies: Implementing solid written procedures for managing these assets.
- Exclusive Control: Broker-dealers must ensure they control the assets they are custodizing.
So, if you thought you could throw in a Bitcoin or two for good measure, think again!
Forget Traditional Securities – It’s All or Nothing!
According to the SEC, the road to custodying digital asset securities involves clearing the slate of any non-digital activities. Imagine being told to hand over all your toys just so you can play with Legos. That’s the kind of fun broker-dealers are signing up for. If they want to dip their toes in the digital asset pool, sweeping out the traditional securities playroom is a must.
What’s a Digital Asset Security, Anyway?
If you think figuring out what qualifies as a digital asset security is simple, we’ve got some bad news for you. The recent case against Ripple is a glaring reminder that even clever folks struggle to pin down this definition. It’s like trying to nail jelly to a wall. The Howey Test, originally designed to sort out what qualifies as a security, is being stretched thin under the weight of digital innovation.
The FINRA Labyrinth: A Slow Journey Ahead
Picture this: you’ve cleaned up your act and are now ready to custody digital asset securities. But first, say hello to the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA). They are your gatekeepers, but their approval process can be as exciting as watching paint dry. Historically, applicants have faced delays and confusion while trying to navigate this regulatory maze.
What About Customer Protection Under SIPA?
Now, let’s talk about the elephant in the room: customer protection. The SEC seems to think that if a broker-dealer fails while custodying digital assets, customers may end up as unsecured creditors during liquidation. However, the reality is a bit more optimistic. Assets in trust that have clear paths of ownership don’t belong to the broker-dealer and, as a result, aren’t subject to distribution among creditors under the Securities Investor Protection Act (SIPA). By leveraging modern practices and technology, broker-dealers can ensure that their clients are adequately protected.
The Bottom Line: A Challenging Road Ahead
In a nutshell, while the SEC’s proposal might aim to bolster innovation in the digital asset market, it’s hard to ignore the considerable hurdles it sets for broker-dealers. Between the regulatory uncertainties, required approvals, and the intense focus on limiting business lines, it’s a challenging journey that may discourage potential players from entering the field. But if you’re up for the challenge, you might just be able to carve out a niche in the digital asset landscape.
+ There are no comments
Add yours