Breaking Down the SEC’s Ruling
In a surprising twist for crypto enthusiasts, the SEC recently admitted that the sale of LBRY Credits (LBC) on the secondary market doesn’t classify them as securities. This revelation came during an appeal hearing of the ongoing LBRY vs. SEC case on January 30, 2023. It’s like the SEC finally decided to pick an actual fight, and guess what? They lost!
Victory for the Crypto Community
Attorney John Deaton, representing tech journalist Naomi Brockwell as amicus curiae, presented a compelling argument that knocked the SEC’s previous assertions out of the park. Imagine a courtroom where instead of a gavel, they use a microscopic magnifying glass to scrutinize the law like they’re deciphering ancient hieroglyphics. Deaton sought clarity on those ambiguous LBC transactions—and boy, did he deliver!
The Stakes of Regulation in Crypto
The SEC had previously won a summary judgment on November 7, 2022, deeming all LBC sales within a six-year span as investment contracts. It’s as though they decided that every used car sale in the last decade also included a warranty that guarantees a buyer a unicorn. Their overarching goal? To gain wider control of the secondary market for crypto assets. But what they actually got was an intellectual smackdown!
A Quote to Remember
Deaton cited the insightful words of commercial contract attorney Lewis Cohen, who examined U.S. security lawsuits since the SEC vs. W.J. Howey Co case. In Cohen’s extensive research, no court had ever acknowledged that the underlying asset in these cases was a security. Talk about a plot twist that leaves the SEC looking like a bad sitcom character!
What Does This Mean for Other Cryptos?
For many in the crypto community, particularly XRP holders, this ruling is akin to finding a pot of gold at the end of a very elusive rainbow. The implications are significant, especially as Ripple faces a securities lawsuit from the SEC regarding XRP tokens. The question on everyone’s mind: can LBC’s case bolster Ripple’s chances?
Twitter Reacts
Social media was abuzz after the ruling, with pro-XRP accounts exclaiming,
“If the SEC admitted LBRY isn’t a security, then they know for sure that #XRP is definitely not a security!”
A sentiment echoed by many who believe this decision could eventually lead to a settlement in Ripple’s case.
Final Thoughts
In the end, John Deaton is being hailed by many as a champ in the fight against the SEC’s regulatory overreach. With continued scrutiny on how the SEC manages crypto assets, one has to wonder: is it high time the SEC got a reality check? Buckle up, crypto world—there’s still a long way to go!
+ There are no comments
Add yours